As I mentioned in my earlier post, my Friday at ALA was filled with comics. The last two comic presentations of the day were 2 panels: the first on Nonfiction graphic novels, the second a discussion with comic creators.
Takeaways from Problem Solving: Teaching STEM with Comics
This panel included:
- Gene Yang, author of Secret Coders, as moderator
- Jeremie Royer, illustrator of Audubon
- Jim McClaine, 7th grade math teacher and self-published author of Solution Squad
- Mike Espinos, Middle grade robotics teacher, author and comics fan.
__________________________
One of the most interesting things that Espinos talked about was how, with STEM, you need to give students the foundation of what STEM they will do, allow them to determine how they want to use those basics in a project, based on their own interests. If you just give all students the same project, you are "giving them a just a recipe, not learning".
For example, if you are teaching students about circuits, teach them how they work. Then let the students implement it in their own project: creating a light-up Ironman heart, or a Green Lantern or something else entirely. Students will be more motivated if they are interested and directing the learning.
This may difficult to do in some of our larger, one hour only workshops, but it struck me as interesting.
___________________________
The panel also recommended some STEAM comics and characters:
- Riri Williams, Ironheart in the Marvel comics
- Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur from Marvel
- Howtoons by various authors
- Secret Coders by Gene Luen Yang & Mike Holmes
- Human Body Theater by Maris Wicks
- Primates by Jim Ottaviani
Takeaway from Comic Creator Panel
I was most interested in a brief discussion about where non-fiction graphic novels should be shelved: with fiction graphic novels, or with nonfiction in the Dewey number of the subject? A couple of library people and I were having this exact same discussion a few weeks ago, and had come to no real conclusions, so I was interested in hearing what a comic creator would say. Philippe Ostermann, the CEO of Dargaud publishing in France, made the point that all topics of books can be made with comics. He prefers it be shelved in with the books on the same topic in nonfiction. Having all the books together on one topic just means people can access the information in a text-only manner, text and illustration, or graphic format. To separate them out creates a "ghetto of comic books".
So, good for Pasadena Public Library for classifying this way!
Ok, my next blog posts will be on topics other than Graphic Novels, so stay tuned!
posted by: Jennifer
Takeaways from Problem Solving: Teaching STEM with Comics
This panel included:
- Gene Yang, author of Secret Coders, as moderator
- Jeremie Royer, illustrator of Audubon
- Jim McClaine, 7th grade math teacher and self-published author of Solution Squad
- Mike Espinos, Middle grade robotics teacher, author and comics fan.
__________________________
One of the most interesting things that Espinos talked about was how, with STEM, you need to give students the foundation of what STEM they will do, allow them to determine how they want to use those basics in a project, based on their own interests. If you just give all students the same project, you are "giving them a just a recipe, not learning".
For example, if you are teaching students about circuits, teach them how they work. Then let the students implement it in their own project: creating a light-up Ironman heart, or a Green Lantern or something else entirely. Students will be more motivated if they are interested and directing the learning.
This may difficult to do in some of our larger, one hour only workshops, but it struck me as interesting.
___________________________
The panel also recommended some STEAM comics and characters:
- Riri Williams, Ironheart in the Marvel comics
- Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur from Marvel
- Howtoons by various authors
- Secret Coders by Gene Luen Yang & Mike Holmes
- Human Body Theater by Maris Wicks
- Primates by Jim Ottaviani
Takeaway from Comic Creator Panel
I was most interested in a brief discussion about where non-fiction graphic novels should be shelved: with fiction graphic novels, or with nonfiction in the Dewey number of the subject? A couple of library people and I were having this exact same discussion a few weeks ago, and had come to no real conclusions, so I was interested in hearing what a comic creator would say. Philippe Ostermann, the CEO of Dargaud publishing in France, made the point that all topics of books can be made with comics. He prefers it be shelved in with the books on the same topic in nonfiction. Having all the books together on one topic just means people can access the information in a text-only manner, text and illustration, or graphic format. To separate them out creates a "ghetto of comic books".
So, good for Pasadena Public Library for classifying this way!
Ok, my next blog posts will be on topics other than Graphic Novels, so stay tuned!
posted by: Jennifer
Comments
Post a Comment